Best Ice Bath Barrel: Ice Barrel vs Coldture Barrel

We see a frequent debate within the cold plunging community whether a traditional (horizontal) tub or a barrel style (vertical) tub is better.

Two of the main brands featured in these debates are Coldture and Ice Barrel.

In this comparative article, we’ll uncover why we prefer and think the ice bath barrel is better, explore its benefits, and compare, head-to-head the Coldture Cold Plunge Barrel and the Ice Barrel.

Why Choose a Barrel Tub Over a Traditional Tub?

Why opt for a barrel tub over the conventional bathtubs that have graced our homes for years?

Here’s a breakdown that may shed light on why we prefer barrels or traditional ice bath tubs.

1,250 Person Survey (SHOCKING)

We conducted a survey on our social medias and we asked people whether they prefered a barrel style or a traditional style tub.

Here are the results:

We suspected that barrel style would be the favorite, but we didn’t expect by this kind of margin…

This made us think deeper about it and we’ve developed this list of why we think barrels are superior:

1. Therapeutic Design:

Barrel tubs, particularly those designed for ice baths, are crafted keeping therapy in mind.

The cylindrical shape ensures a deep and consistent water level, allowing for a more uniform immersion experience. Traditional tubs, with their sloping sides, may not offer the same depth throughout.

2. Space-Efficient:

Given their upright design, barrel tubs often take up less horizontal space than traditional tubs.

This is particularly advantageous for smaller homes, patios, or yards, where space conservation is key.

3. Portability:

Some barrel tubs, like the Coldture, are inflatable, making them highly portable.

This flexibility is something traditional tubs, made of ceramic or acrylic, can’t offer.

Even non-inflatable barrel tubs, given their standalone nature, can be relocated more easily than built-in bathtubs.

4. Temperature Retention:

Barrel tubs, especially those with insulated walls, are designed for optimal temperature retention, which is crucial for cold immersion therapy.

Traditional tubs might not retain temperature as efficiently, leading to frequent water changes or adjustments.

5. Aesthetic Appeal:

For some, the rustic and natural look of a barrel tub, especially when placed outdoors, provides a unique aesthetic appeal, blending seamlessly with garden landscapes and offering a spa-like ambiance.

Choosing between an ice bath barrel tub and a traditional tub will depend on individual preferences and needs.

However, for those specifically seeking the therapeutic benefits of cold plunges or simply desiring a unique and efficient soaking experience, barrel tubs present a compelling option.

Comparing Ice Bath Barrels: Coldture vs Ice Barrel

With the rising popularity of cold water immersion therapy, many individuals are turning to ice bath barrels to experience the benefits right in their own homes.

Among the leaders in this niche are the Coldture Barrel Cold Plunge Tub and the Ice Barrel.

Both have garnered significant attention, but which one is right for you? Let’s dive into a comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision.

https://idyllic-quiz-widget.web.app/quiz-widget.js

Coldture Cold Plunge Barrel Tub: A Portable Choice

• Portability: The standout feature of the Coldture Barrel is unquestionably its inflatable design. This makes it not only portable but also ideal for those with changing spatial needs. Whether you’re shifting houses or simply rearranging your outdoor space, this barrel is a breeze to move.

• Capacity: With a capacity ranging from 300-350 liters (80-90 gallons), the Coldture offers a generous volume for individual use. This should cater to the needs of most users, ensuring a full-body immersion experience.

• Design & Build: Sporting external dimensions of 100cm x 95cm (H x W), the barrel is consciously designed to cater to taller individuals, ensuring that they don’t feel cramped. Furthermore, despite its inflatable nature, users will be pleasantly surprised by its rock-hard firmness and sturdy structure once inflated.

• Maintenance & Drainage: The Coldture distinguishes itself with built-in hose and drainage connections, which is a testament to its user-centric design. This means less fuss and mess when changing or maintaining the water. Additionally, its smaller capacity can be an advantage, allowing for quicker and more efficient water temperature management.

• Extras & Enhancements: Beyond its core features, the Coldture boasts insulated walls that effectively retain water temperature, a crucial aspect for cold therapy. The buckled PVC cover provides added insulation and safety. The inclusion of steps and a lid just adds cherries on top, ensuring that users have everything they need right out of the box.

• Water Chiller Compatible: The Coldture Barrel is compatible with water chillers, which help maintain freezing cold water temperatures, without the need to add ice.

Pros

• Highly portable.
• Suitable for taller individuals.
• Takes up a smaller footprint, fitting into tighter spaces.
• Insulated walls help maintain temperature.
• Comes with a 1-year warranty.
• Indoor and outdoor use
• Compatible with water chillers

Cons

• Smaller capacity than the Ice Barrel.
• Inflation might be a concern for some users.
• One-year warranty, in contrast to the Ice Barrel’s lifetime warranty.

Ice Barrel: Durable and Efficient

• Design: The Ice Barrel’s upright design stands out, offering users a unique immersion experience that allows for a deeper plunge, concentrating on full-body immersion with reduced spatial requirements.

• Material & Durability: Its construction from recycled plastic material speaks volumes about its eco-friendliness without compromising on strength. The use of linear low-density polyethylene (LLDPE), a safe and non-toxic BPA-free, medical-grade material, ensures that users don’t have to worry about harmful chemicals or degradation over time.

• Capacity: The Ice Barrel edges ahead in terms of volume, boasting a capacity of 397 liters (105 gallons). This increased volume can be beneficial for those seeking prolonged immersion sessions or those who prefer a more spacious interior.

• Portability & Weight: While it can’t be deflated like the Coldture, its construction from lightweight material means it isn’t as cumbersome as one might think. However, it will require a dedicated space given its solid structure.

• Extras & Add-ons: The Ice Barrel offers a comprehensive package, which includes a sturdy stand, ensuring the barrel is at a comfortable height for users. Additionally, the provided lid, steps, and cover not only add to its functionality but also enhance user convenience, making the plunge experience smooth and hassle-free.

• Water Chiller Compatible: The Ice Barrel is compatible with water chillers, which help maintain ice cold temperatures, without the need to add ice.

Pros

• Extremely durable and made from safe materials.
• Greater water capacity.
• Comes with a lifetime warranty.
• Includes all necessary accessories.
• Indoor and outdoor use
• Compatible with water chillers
• Comes in 2 colorways (black or tan)

Cons

• Not as portable as the Coldture due to its solid structure.
• Takes up more space.

Price Point: A Level Playing Field

Interestingly, both the Coldture Cold Plunge Barrel and the Ice Barrel are priced at $1,119.00. This makes the choice even more focused on the features and pros/cons, rather than budget considerations.

Head-To-Head: Ice Barrel vs Coldture

body { font-family: Arial, sans-serif; margin: 20px; background-color: #f4f4f4; } h2 { text-align: center; color: #333; margin-bottom: 20px; } table { border-collapse: collapse; width: 100%; background-color: #ffffff; box-shadow: 0px 0px 10px rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.1); border: 1px solid #ddd; } th, td { padding: 15px; text-align: left; border: 1px solid #ddd; } th { background-color: #00D084; color: white; } tr:nth-child(even) { background-color: #f2f2f2; } td:first-child { font-weight: bold; } table:hover tr { opacity: 0.7; } table:hover tr:hover { opacity: 1; }

FEATURE	COLDTURE COLD PLUNGE BARREL	ICE BARREL
Portability	Portable (inflatable)	Not as portable (Solid structure)
Capacity	300-350 Liters (80-90gl)	397 liters (105 gallons)
Dimensions	100cm x 95cm (H x W)	Effective upright design
Material	Insulated Walls and Buckled PVC Cover	Made from recycled plastic material, LLDPE
Extras	Steps and lid included	Stand, lid, steps, and cover included
Warranty	One Year Warranty	Lifetime Warranty
Price	$1,119.00	$1,119.00

Conclusion: Which Ice Bath Barrel is For You?

Choosing the best ice bath barrel, between the Coldture Cold Plunge Barrel and the Ice Barrel, boils down to your individual needs; both are surely to enhance your cold plunging sessions.

If portability and space conservation are priorities, the Coldture might be your best bet. On the other hand, if you’re looking for something extremely durable with a bit more capacity, the Ice Barrel has you covered.

Both products are well-regarded, so you’re making a solid choice either way. Remember to always prioritize what fits best with your lifestyle and space.

Get Cold.® 🥶